id
type
5
status
21
review version
0
cleanup version
0
pending deletion
0
created at
2025-10-23 22:59:25
updated at
2025-10-23 22:59:26
url
https://1000yearview.substack.com/p/america-a-great-idea-for-a-nation
url length
69
url crc
44661
url crc32
1572187765
location type
1
canonical status
10
canonical page id
domain id
domain tld
2211
domain parts
0
originating warc id
-
originating url
https://data.commoncrawl.org/crawl-data/CC-MAIN-2025-33/segments/1754151280903.0/warc/CC-MAIN-20250811192912-20250811222912-00588.warc.gz
source type
11
page id
title
excerpt
content
Monument at Valley Forge National Park. Note the classically American use of both nationalistic (“place of sacrifice,” “our fathers,” “our children”) and idealistic (“union,” “liberty,” “progress”) language. Source: Author’s Trip to Valley Forge, PAIs America an idea or a nation? As my own immigrant experience shows, the answer is both. My citizenship application asked if I support the Constitution and form of government of the United States. Score one point for America-as-idea. However, I was only eligible to file for citizenship after marrying an American (not an idea) and fulfilling residency (not ideological) requirements. Score one point for America-as-nation. Furthermore, my two children became citizens simply by being born on American soil. No one in the delivery room asked if they supported the Constitution and form of government of the United States. And no one can rescind their citizenship if they grow up to be monarchists. Score another point for America-as-nation.I ask this...
author
Ben Koan
updated
1762871392
block type
0
extracted fields
36
extracted bits
article author
full content
detected location
0
detected language
1 (English)
category id
index version
2025110801
paywall score
0
spam phrases
0
text nonlatin
0
text cyrillic
0
text characters
9158
text words
1903
text unique words
745
text lines
113
text sentences
79
text paragraphs
24
text words per sentence
24
text matched phrases
2
text matched dictionaries
3
links self subdomains
0
links other subdomains
0
links other domains
1
links spam adult
0
links spam random
0
links spam expired
0
links ext activities
0
links ext ecommerce
0
links ext finance
0
links ext crypto
0
links ext booking
0
links ext news
6
links ext leaks
0
links ext ugc
13
links ext klim
0
links ext generic
0
image author
featured image